Jump to content

1989 Spanish general election

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

1989 Spanish general election
← 1986 29 October 1989[a] 1993 →
All 350 seats in the Congress of Deputies and 208 (of 254) seats in the Senate
176[b] seats needed for a majority in the Congress of Deputies
Opinion polls
Registered29,604,055 Green arrow up1.7%
Turnout20,646,365 (69.7%)
Red arrow down0.8 pp
  First party Second party Third party
 
Leader Felipe González José María Aznar Miquel Roca
Party PSOE PP CiU
Leader since 28 September 1979 4 September 1989 4 July 1982
Leader's seat Madrid Madrid Barcelona
Last election 184 seats, 44.1% 105 seats, 26.0%[c] 18 seats, 5.0%
Seats won 175 107 18
Seat change Red arrow down9 Green arrow up2 Blue arrow right0
Popular vote 8,115,568 5,285,972 1,032,243
Percentage 39.6% 25.8% 5.0%
Swing Red arrow down4.5 pp Red arrow down0.2 pp Blue arrow right0.0 pp
  Fourth party Fifth party Sixth party
 
Leader Julio Anguita Adolfo Suárez Iñaki Anasagasti
Party IU CDS EAJ/PNV
Leader since 12 February 1989 29 July 1982 1986
Leader's seat Madrid Madrid Biscay
Last election 7 seats, 4.6% 19 seats, 9.2% 6 seats, 1.5%
Seats won 17 14 5
Seat change Green arrow up10 Red arrow down5 Red arrow down1
Popular vote 1,858,588 1,617,716 254,681
Percentage 9.1% 7.9% 1.2%
Swing Green arrow up4.5 pp Red arrow down1.3 pp Red arrow down0.3 pp
Map of Spain showcasing seat distribution by Congress of Deputies constituency
Map of Spain showcasing winning party's strength by constituency
Map of Spain showcasing winning party's strength by autonomous community
Prime Minister before election

Felipe González
PSOE

Prime Minister after election

Felipe González
PSOE

The 1989 Spanish general election was held on Sunday, 29 October 1989,[a] to elect the 4th Cortes Generales of the Kingdom of Spain. All 350 seats in the Congress of Deputies were up for election, as well as 208 of 254 seats in the Senate. An election had not been due until 28 July 1990 at latest,[d] but Prime Minister Felipe González called for a snap election nine months ahead of schedule, allegedly on the need of implementing tough economic measures.[2] González hoped to capitalize on a still strong economy and his party's electoral success in a European Parliament election held in June, after a troubled legislature which had seen an increase of social protest on his government's economic policy and the calling of a massive general strike in 1988.[3]

The election was regarded as one of the most controversial in the democratic history of Spain. Close results in many constituencies, coupled with severe flaws in electoral register data, an inefficient structure of the electoral administration and the ongoing political struggle between the ruling Spanish Socialist Workers' Party (PSOE) and the opposition parties over the Socialist absolute majority in the Congress of Deputies, led to a major scandal when election results in a number of constituencies were contested under accusations of irregularities and fraud.[4] Judicial courts were forced to intervene, determining by-elections for Murcia, Pontevedra and Melilla. The issue was appealed to the Constitutional Court of Spain, which overruled previous rulings and validated the vote in Melilla only, with a new election being held on 25 March 1990.[5] In the end, the disputed seat was won by the People's Party (PP), depriving the PSOE of its 176th seat in Congress–and with it, the outright majority it had held since 1982.[6]

The election saw an erosion in popular support for the incumbent Socialists, who nonetheless emerged again as the largest party by a decisive margin, with 68 more seats than the PP. As a result, Felipe González was able to be re-elected for a third consecutive term in office with confidence and supply support from the Canarian Independent Groups (AIC). The newly amalgamated PP, led into the election by José María Aznar, exceeded initial expectations and slightly improved on the People's Coalition 1986 result while performing better than in the June European Parliament election.[7] Julio Anguita's left-wing coalition, United Left (IU), scored a remarkable success by doubling its 1986 totals, whereas Adolfo Suárez's Democratic and Social Centre (CDS) fell short of its goal of becoming a government alternative and lost votes and seats.[8][9]

Overview

[edit]

Electoral system

[edit]

The Spanish Cortes Generales were envisaged as an imperfect bicameral system. The Congress of Deputies had greater legislative power than the Senate, having the ability to vote confidence in or withdraw it from a prime minister and to override Senate vetoes by an absolute majority of votes. Nonetheless, the Senate possessed a few exclusive (yet limited in number) functions—such as its role in constitutional amendment—which were not subject to the Congress' override.[10][11] Voting for the Cortes Generales was on the basis of universal suffrage, which comprised all nationals over 18 years of age and in full enjoyment of their political rights.[12][13]

For the Congress of Deputies, 348 seats were elected using the D'Hondt method and a closed list proportional representation, with an electoral threshold of three percent of valid votes—which included blank ballots—being applied in each constituency. Seats were allocated to constituencies, corresponding to the provinces of Spain, with each being allocated an initial minimum of two seats and the remaining 248 being distributed in proportion to their populations. Ceuta and Melilla were allocated the two remaining seats, which were elected using plurality voting.[14][15] The use of the electoral method resulted in an effective threshold based on the district magnitude and the distribution of votes among candidacies.[16]

As a result of the aforementioned allocation, each Congress multi-member constituency was entitled the following seats:[17]

Seats Constituencies
33 Madrid
32 Barcelona(–1)
16 Valencia
12 Seville
10 Alicante, Biscay, Málaga(+1)
9 Asturias, Cádiz, La Coruña, Murcia(+1)
8 Pontevedra
7 Córdoba, Granada, Guipúzcoa, Las Palmas, Santa Cruz de Tenerife(+1), Zaragoza(–1)
6 Badajoz, Balearics, Jaén
5 Almería, Cáceres, Cantabria, Castellón, Ciudad Real, Gerona, Huelva, León, Lugo, Navarre, Orense, Tarragona, Toledo, Valladolid
4 Álava, Albacete, Burgos, La Rioja, Lérida, Salamanca
3 Ávila, Cuenca, Guadalajara, Huesca, Palencia, Segovia, Soria, Teruel, Zamora(–1)

For the Senate, 208 seats were elected using an open list partial block voting system, with electors voting for individual candidates instead of parties. In constituencies electing four seats, electors could vote for up to three candidates; in those with two or three seats, for up to two candidates; and for one candidate in single-member districts. Each of the 47 peninsular provinces was allocated four seats, whereas for insular provinces, such as the Balearic and Canary Islands, districts were the islands themselves, with the larger—Majorca, Gran Canaria and Tenerife—being allocated three seats each, and the smaller—Menorca, Ibiza–Formentera, Fuerteventura, La Gomera, El Hierro, Lanzarote and La Palma—one each. Ceuta and Melilla elected two seats each. Additionally, autonomous communities could appoint at least one senator each and were entitled to one additional senator per each million inhabitants.[18][19]

Election date

[edit]

The term of each chamber of the Cortes Generales—the Congress and the Senate—expired four years from the date of their previous election, unless they were dissolved earlier. The election decree was required to be issued no later than the twenty-fifth day prior to the date of expiry of parliament and published on the following day in the Official State Gazette (BOE), with election day taking place between the fifty-fourth and the sixtieth day from publication.[20] The previous election was held on 22 June 1986, which meant that the legislature's term would expire on 22 June 1990. The election decree was required to be published in the BOE no later than 29 May 1990, with the election taking place on the sixtieth day from publication, setting the latest possible election date for the Cortes Generales on Saturday, 28 July 1990.

The prime minister had the prerogative to dissolve both chambers at any given time—either jointly or separately—and call a snap election, provided that no motion of no confidence was in process, no state of emergency was in force and that dissolution did not occur before one year had elapsed since the previous one. Additionally, both chambers were to be dissolved and a new election called if an investiture process failed to elect a prime minister within a two-month period from the first ballot.[21] Barred this exception, there was no constitutional requirement for simultaneous elections for the Congress and the Senate. Still, as of 2024 there has been no precedent of separate elections taking place under the 1978 Constitution.

While the opposition to the PSOE government had pressed for a snap election since the general strike in December 1988, it was not until the PSOE's success in the 1989 European Parliament election, the end of the Spanish rotational Presidency of the Council of the European Union in June and the need for tough economic measures before the end of the year that Prime Minister Felipe González chose to trigger an early dissolution of the Cortes.[22][23][24] On 25 August 1989, governmental sources confirmed that González would be calling an autumn election in the following days.[25]

The Cortes Generales were officially dissolved on 2 September 1989 after the publication of the dissolution decree in the BOE, setting the election date for 29 October and scheduling for both chambers to reconvene on 21 November.[17]

Background

[edit]

Felipe González's second term as prime minister was characterized by economic growth, with public investments favoured by the Structural Funds coming from the European Economic Community to which Spain had recently accessed. The GDP grew by around or above 5% between 1987 and 1989 and unemployment decreased from 20.6% to 16.9%.[26][27] This period saw a consolidation of welfare system reforms initiated during González's first term, allowed through a better financing derived from a relatively progressive tax system. But the economic expansion fostered by the government's liberal policies brought about an increase in wealth differences and of inequality, leading to social unrest and a loss of popularity for the ruling Spanish Socialist Workers' Party (PSOE), made apparent in the local, regional and European Parliament elections.[28] In December 1988, the two major trade unions in Spain, CCOO and UGT, called a general strike which succeeded in paralyzing the country and in forcing González's government to negotiate a partial withdrawal of its economic policies.[3][29][30]

Concurrently, the opposition People's Alliance (AP) suffered from a profound internal crisis since the 1986 election, which had seen the break up of the People's Coalition and the resignation of party leader Manuel Fraga.[31] His successor, Antonio Hernández Mancha, proved unable to improve AP's electoral fortunes and saw his political credibility decimated after an unsuccessful attempt to bring down Felipe González through a motion of no confidence in March 1987.[32][33][34] Hernández Mancha ended up quitting in early 1989,[35][36] with Fraga returning as a caretaker leader who oversaw the merging of AP with its former allies, the People's Democratic Party (PDP) and the Liberal Party (PL), into the new People's Party (PP).[37][38] Intending his national leadership as temporary, Fraga appointed a then-unknown President of Castile and León José María Aznar as his successor.[39][40]

The 1986–1989 period saw an increase in the terror activity of the ETA Basque separatist group. This reached its peak with the Hipercor bombing on 19 June 1987, which—with 21 dead and 45 injured—would eventually become the deadliest attack in ETA's history. Other deadly attacks included the Plaza República Dominicana bombing on 14 July 1986, three weeks after the previous general election and one day before the newly elected Cortes re-assembled, which left 12 dead and 32 injured; and the 1987 Zaragoza Barracks bombing, with 11 dead—including 5 children—and 88 injured. Concurrently, the PSOE government introduced a policy of dispersion of imprisoned terrorists throughout the entire Spanish territory in order to restrict contacts between them and prevent terrorist organizations from organizing themselves from prison.[41] Political parties signed several anti-terrorist agreements, such as the Ajuria Enea Pact or the Madrid Agreement on Terrorism, aimed at increasing inter-party cooperation on the issue. In January 1989, ETA declared a ceasefire in order to start negotiation talks in Algiers with the Socialist government,[42] but no successful conclusion was reached and ETA resumed its violence campaign.[43][44]

Parliamentary composition

[edit]

The tables below show the composition of the parliamentary groups in both chambers at the time of dissolution.[45][46]

Parties and candidates

[edit]

The electoral law allowed for parties and federations registered in the interior ministry, coalitions and groupings of electors to present lists of candidates. Parties and federations intending to form a coalition ahead of an election were required to inform the relevant Electoral Commission within ten days of the election call, whereas groupings of electors needed to secure the signature of at least one percent of the electorate in the constituencies for which they sought election, disallowing electors from signing for more than one list of candidates.[49]

Below is a list of the main parties and electoral alliances which contested the election:

Candidacy Parties and
alliances 		Leading candidate Ideology Previous result Gov. Ref.
Votes (%) Con. Sen.
PSOE
List
 Felipe González Social democracy 44.06% 184 124 checkY
PP
List
 José María Aznar Conservatism
Christian democracy 		25.97%[c] 105 63 ☒N
CDS
List
 Adolfo Suárez Centrism
Liberalism 		9.22% 19 3 ☒N
CiU
List
 Miquel Roca Catalan nationalism
Centrism 		5.02% 18 8 ☒N
IU
List
 Julio Anguita Socialism
Communism 		4.63% 7 0 ☒N
EAJ/PNV
List
 Iñaki Anasagasti Basque nationalism
Christian democracy
Conservative liberalism 		1.53% 6 7 ☒N
HB
List
 Iñaki Esnaola Basque independence
Abertzale left
Revolutionary socialism 		1.15% 5 1 ☒N
EE
List
 Koro Garmendia Basque nationalism
Social democracy 		0.53% 2 0 ☒N
CG
List
 Senén Bernárdez Galician nationalism
Centrism 		0.40% 1 0 ☒N
PAR
List
 José María Mur Regionalism
Centrism 		0.36% 1 0 ☒N
AIC
List
 Manuel Hermoso Regionalism
Canarian nationalism
Conservatism 		0.33% 1 1 ☒N
UV
List
 Vicente González Lizondo Blaverism
Conservatism 		0.32% 1 0 ☒N
PA
List
 Alejandro Rojas-Marcos Andalusian nationalism
Social democracy 		0.47% 0 0 ☒N
EA
List
 Joseba Azcarraga Basque nationalism
Social democracy 		New ☒N

The People's Party (PP) and Navarrese People's Union (UPN) signed a coalition agreement on 8 September 1989 to run together in Navarre, renewing the alliance in existence between the PP's predecessors, the People's Alliance (AP) and the People's Coalition (CP), and UPN, in both the 1982 and 1986 elections.[50]

Campaign period

[edit]

Despite Aznar's designation as PP candidate, the opposition remained divided and weak on the road to the 1989 election. This, coupled with a buoyant economy, made a new PSOE victory inevitable. The electoral campaign, thus, focused on whether the Socialists would be able to maintain their absolute majority on the Congress of Deputies for a third term in office. United Left had also appointed a new leader, Julio Anguita, and had high expectations to increase their parliamentary representation from the 7 seats they had won in 1986. During the campaign, Felipe González pledged that this would be the last time he would stand for the office of Prime Minister. He would eventually stand for two more elections, until 1996.[51]

Party slogans

[edit]
Party or alliance Original slogan English translation Ref.
PSOE « España, en progreso » "Spain, in progress" [52][53][54]
PP « ¡Palabra! » "Promise!" [52][53][54]
CDS « Capaces de hacerlo » "[We are] capable of doing it" [52]
IU « Somos la alternativa » "We are the alternative" [52][54]
CiU « Força! » "Forward!" [52]

Opinion polls

[edit]
Main article: Opinion polling for the 1989 Spanish general election

Results

[edit]

Congress of Deputies

[edit]
For results by autonomous community/constituency, see Results breakdown of the 1989 Spanish general election (Congress).
← Summary of the 29 October 1989 Congress of Deputies election results →
Parties and alliances Popular vote Seats
Votes % ±pp Total +/−
Spanish Socialist Workers' Party (PSOE)1 8,115,568 39.60 –4.46 175 –9
People's Party (PP)1 2 5,285,972 25.79 –0.18 107 +2
United Left (IU) 1,858,588 9.07 +4.44 17 +10
Democratic and Social Centre (CDS) 1,617,716 7.89 –1.33 14 –5
Convergence and Union (CiU) 1,032,243 5.04 +0.02 18 ±0
Basque Nationalist Party (EAJ/PNV) 254,681 1.24 –0.29 5 –1
Ruiz-Mateos Group (Ruiz-Mateos) 219,883 1.07 New 0 ±0
Popular Unity (HB) 217,278 1.06 –0.09 4 –1
Andalusian Party (PA) 212,687 1.04 +0.57 2 +2
Green List (LV) 158,034 0.77 +0.61 0 ±0
The Greens–Green List (LV–LV) 157,103 0.77 +0.61 0 ±0
Ecologist Party of the Basque Country (PEE–(LV)) 931 0.00 New 0 ±0
Valencian Union (UV) 144,924 0.71 New 2 +1
Basque Solidarity (EA) 136,955 0.67 New 2 +2
The Ecologist Greens (LVE) 136,335 0.67 New 0 ±0
Basque Country Left (EE) 105,238 0.51 –0.02 2 ±0
Workers' Party of Spain–Communist Unity (PTE–UC)3 86,257 0.42 –0.72 0 ±0
Republican Left of Catalonia (ERC) 84,756 0.41 –0.01 0 ±0
Workers' Socialist Party (PST) 81,218 0.40 +0.01 0 ±0
Regionalist Aragonese Party (PAR) 71,733 0.35 –0.01 1 ±0
Canarian Independent Groups (AIC) 64,767 0.32 –0.01 1 ±0
Communist Party of the Peoples of Spain (PCPE) 62,664 0.31 New 0 ±0
Galician Nationalist Bloc (BNG) 47,763 0.23 +0.10 0 ±0
Galician Coalition (CG) 45,821 0.22 –0.18 0 –1
Valencian People's Union (UPV) 40,767 0.20 ±0.00 0 ±0
Galician Socialist Party–Galician Left (PSG–EG) 34,131 0.17 –0.06 0 ±0
Green Alternative–Ecologist Movement of Catalonia (AV–MEC)4 25,978 0.13 –0.02 0 ±0
Spanish Phalanx of the CNSO (FE–JONS) 24,025 0.12 –0.10 0 ±0
Canarian Nationalist Assembly (ACN)5 21,539 0.11 –0.07 0 ±0
Spanish Vertex Ecological Development Revindication (VERDE) 21,235 0.10 –0.04 0 ±0
Social Democratic Coalition (CSD)6 17,095 0.08 +0.06 0 ±0
Humanist Party (PH) 15,936 0.08 New 0 ±0
Galician Nationalist Party–Galicianist Party (PNG–PG) 14,411 0.07 New 0 ±0
Alliance for the Republic (AxR)7 12,807 0.06 –0.05 0 ±0
United Extremadura (EU) 10,984 0.05 –0.03 0 ±0
Nationalist Left (PSM–ENE) 7,989 0.04 ±0.00 0 ±0
Revolutionary Workers' Party of Spain (PORE) 7,906 0.04 +0.01 0 ±0
Independents of Gran Canaria (IGC) 6,371 0.03 New 0 ±0
Asturianist Party (PAS) 5,414 0.03 New 0 ±0
Centrist Unity–Democratic Spanish Party (PED) 4,942 0.02 +0.01 0 ±0
Galician People's Front (FPG) 3,657 0.02 New 0 ±0
Regional Party of Madrid (PAM) 3,396 0.02 New 0 ±0
Group of Madrid Radicals (GRM) 3,330 0.02 New 0 ±0
Asturian Nationalist Unity (UNA) 3,218 0.02 New 0 ±0
Aragonese Union (UA–CHA) 3,156 0.02 New 0 ±0
Valencian Nationalist Left–Valencian Regional Union (ENV–URV) 2,988 0.01 ±0.00 0 ±0
Regionalist Party of the Leonese Country (PREPAL) 2,962 0.01 ±0.00 0 ±0
Balearic Union (UB) 2,883 0.01 New 0 ±0
United Ceuta (CEU) 2,760 0.01 New 0 ±0
7 Green Stars (SEV) 1,411 0.01 New 0 ±0
Green Movement (MV) 1,368 0.01 New 0 ±0
Independent Citizen Group (ACI) 1,359 0.01 New 0 ±0
Nationalist Party of Castile and León (PANCAL) 1,199 0.01 ±0.00 0 ±0
Cantonalist Party of the Alicantine Country (Alicantón) 1,041 0.01 New 0 ±0
Spanish Democratic Republican Action (ARDE) 975 0.00 New 0 ±0
Radicals for Cantabria (RxC) 904 0.00 New 0 ±0
Independent Spanish Phalanx (FEI) 827 0.00 New 0 ±0
Lanzarote Assembly (Tagoror) 472 0.00 New 0 ±0
Regionalist Party of Guadalajara (PRGU) 426 0.00 New 0 ±0
Balearic Radical Party (PRB) 398 0.00 New 0 ±0
Spanish Nationalist Party of Melilla (PNEM) 301 0.00 New 0 ±0
Proverist Party (PPr) 245 0.00 ±0.00 0 ±0
Revolutionary Communist League–Communist Movement (LCR–MC)8 0 0.00 ±0.00 0 ±0
Communist Party of Spain (Marxist–Leninist) (PCE (m–l))9 0 0.00 –0.14 0 ±0
Blank ballots 141,795 0.69 +0.09
Total 20,493,682 350 ±0
Valid votes 20,493,682 99.26 +0.83
Invalid votes 152,683 0.74 –0.83
Votes cast / turnout 20,646,365 69.74 –0.75
Abstentions 8,957,690 30.26 +0.75
Registered voters 29,604,055
Sources[55][56]
Footnotes:
Popular vote
PSOE
 
 39.60%
PP
 
 25.79%
IU
 
 9.07%
CDS
 
 7.89%
CiU
 
 5.04%
EAJ/PNV
 
 1.24%
Ruiz-Mateos
 
 1.07%
HB
 
 1.06%
PA
 
 1.04%
UV
 
 0.71%
EA
 
 0.67%
EE
 
 0.51%
PAR
 
 0.35%
AIC
 
 0.32%
Others
 
 4.95%
Blank ballots
 
 0.69%
Seats
PSOE
 
 50.00%
PP
 
 30.57%
CiU
 
 5.14%
IU
 
 4.86%
CDS
 
 4.00%
EAJ/PNV
 
 1.43%
HB
 
 1.14%
PA
 
 0.57%
UV
 
 0.57%
EA
 
 0.57%
EE
 
 0.57%
PAR
 
 0.29%
AIC
 
 0.29%

Senate

[edit]
← Summary of the 29 October 1989 Senate of Spain election results →
Parties and alliances Popular vote Seats
Votes % ±pp Total +/−
Spanish Socialist Workers' Party (PSOE)1 22,272,484 40.14 –4.38 107 –17
People's Party (PP)1 2 14,459,290 26.06 –0.03 78 +15
United Left (IU) 4,866,930 8.77 +4.12 1 +1
Democratic and Social Centre (CDS)1 4,218,268 7.60 –0.57 1 –2
Convergence and Union (CiU) 2,937,029 5.29 +0.01 10 +2
Basque Nationalist Party (EAJ/PNV) 742,058 1.34 –0.34 4 –3
Andalusian Party (PA) 638,137 1.15 +0.61 0 ±0
Popular Unity (HB) 631,299 1.14 –0.08 3 +2
Basque Solidarity (EA) 398,922 0.72 New 0 ±0
Ruiz-Mateos Group (Ruiz-Mateos) 391,939 0.71 New 0 ±0
Valencian Union (UV) 336,379 0.61 +0.20 0 ±0
The Ecologist Greens (LVE) 300,390 0.54 New 0 ±0
Basque Country Left (EE) 299,794 0.54 –0.02 0 ±0
The Greens–Green List (LV–LV) 273,310 0.49 +0.29 0 ±0
Workers' Party of Spain–Communist Unity (PTE–UC)3 267,683 0.48 –0.69 0 ±0
Aragonese Party (PAR) 239,550 0.43 –0.03 0 ±0
Republican Left of Catalonia (ERC) 239,532 0.43 –0.03 0 ±0
Communists in the Senate Coalition (CS) 151,563 0.27 New 0 ±0
Galician Nationalist Bloc (BNG) 144,544 0.26 +0.11 0 ±0
Galician Coalition (CG) 133,989 0.24 –0.19 0 ±0
Valencian People's Union (UPV) 133,327 0.24 –0.01 0 ±0
Workers' Socialist Party (PST) 124,597 0.22 +0.07 0 ±0
Canarian Independent Groups (AIC) 113,524 0.20 –0.03 2 +1
Galician Socialist Party–Galician Left (PSG–EG) 101,432 0.18 –0.06 0 ±0
Spanish Vertex Ecological Development Revindication (VERDE) 99,949 0.18 –0.09 0 ±0
Green Alternative–Ecologist Movement of Catalonia (AV–MEC)4 85,078 0.15 +0.02 0 ±0
Spanish Phalanx of the CNSO (FE–JONS) 71,859 0.13 –0.19 0 ±0
Galician Nationalist Party–Galicianist Party (PNG–PG) 58,054 0.10 New 0 ±0
United Extremadura (EU) 44,872 0.08 –0.03 0 ±0
Canarian Nationalist Assembly (ACN)5 39,568 0.07 –0.02 0 ±0
Humanist Party (PH) 39,436 0.07 New 0 ±0
Regional Party of Madrid (PAM) 23,998 0.04 New 0 ±0
Alliance for the Republic (AxR)6 23,692 0.04 ±0.00 0 ±0
Lanzarote Independents Group (AIL) 17,768 0.03 +0.01 0 ±0
Spanish Catholic Movement (MCE) 17,588 0.03 New 0 ±0
Asturianist Party (PAS) 17,380 0.03 New 0 ±0
Nationalist Left (PSM–ENE) 15,814 0.03 ±0.00 0 ±0
Regionalist Party of the Leonese Country (PREPAL) 15,742 0.03 +0.01 0 ±0
Asturian People's Union (UPA) 13,977 0.03 New 0 ±0
Group of Madrid Radicals (GRM) 13,576 0.02 New 0 ±0
Aragonese Union (UA–CHA) 12,282 0.02 New 0 ±0
Independents of Gran Canaria (IGC) 12,138 0.02 New 0 ±0
Asturian Nationalist Unity (UNA) 10,956 0.02 New 0 ±0
Independent Solution (SI) 9,910 0.02 New 0 ±0
Nationalist Party of Castile and León (PANCAL) 8,694 0.02 +0.01 0 ±0
Revolutionary Workers' Party of Spain (PORE) 7,301 0.01 –0.03 0 ±0
Natural Culture (CN) 6,633 0.01 –0.01 0 ±0
Galician People's Front (FPG) 6,249 0.01 New 0 ±0
Balearic Union (UB) 6,054 0.01 New 0 ±0
United Ceuta (CEU) 5,462 0.01 New 0 ±0
Centrist Unity–Democratic Spanish Party (PED) 5,434 0.01 New 0 ±0
Majorera Assembly (AM) 5,268 0.01 ±0.00 1 ±0
Spanish Democratic Republican Action (ARDE) 5,016 0.01 New 0 ±0
Alicanton Alicantine Coalition (COA) 4,099 0.01 New 0 ±0
Liberal and Social Democratic Coalition (CSD y L)7 3,269 0.01 ±0.00 0 ±0
Regionalist Party of Castilla–La Mancha (PRCM) 3,267 0.01 New 0 ±0
Valencian Nationalist Left–Valencian Regional Union (ENV–URV) 2,989 0.01 ±0.00 0 ±0
Radicals for Cantabria (RxC) 2,977 0.01 New 0 ±0
Independent Citizen Group (ACI) 2,846 0.01 New 0 ±0
Independent Spanish Phalanx (FEI) 2,259 0.00 New 0 ±0
Proverist Party (PPr) 2,053 0.00 –0.01 0 ±0
Regionalist Party of Guadalajara (PRGU) 1,819 0.00 New 0 ±0
Independents of Almeria and Province (IAYP) 1,576 0.00 New 0 ±0
Seven Green Stars (SEV) 1,402 0.00 New 0 ±0
Independent Herrenian Group (AHI) 1,219 0.00 New 1 +1
Lanzarote Assembly (Tagoror) 607 0.00 New 0 ±0
Balearic Radical Party (PRB) 569 0.00 New 0 ±0
Spanish Nationalist Party of Melilla (PNEM) 551 0.00 New 0 ±0
Spanish Action (AE) 444 0.00 New 0 ±0
Blank ballots[h] 334,118 1.67 +0.10
Total 55,481,782 208 ±0
Valid votes 19,974,111 96.57 –0.11
Invalid votes 710,101 3.43 +0.11
Votes cast / turnout 20,684,212 69.87 –0.45
Abstentions 8,919,843 30.13 +0.45
Registered voters 29,604,055
Sources[46][55][56][57]
Footnotes:
Popular vote
PSOE
 
 40.14%
PP
 
 26.06%
IU
 
 8.77%
CDS
 
 7.60%
CiU
 
 5.29%
EAJ/PNV
 
 1.34%
PA
 
 1.15%
HB
 
 1.14%
AIC
 
 0.20%
AM
 
 0.01%
AHI
 
 0.00%
Others
 
 7.68%
Blank ballots
 
 1.67%
Seats
PSOE
 
 51.44%
PP
 
 37.50%
CiU
 
 4.81%
EAJ/PNV
 
 1.92%
HB
 
 1.44%
AIC
 
 0.96%
IU
 
 0.48%
CDS
 
 0.48%
AM
 
 0.48%
AHI
 
 0.48%

Maps

[edit]
  • Election results by Congress of Deputies constituency.
    Election results by Congress of Deputies constituency.
  • Winner strength by constituency.
    Winner strength by constituency.
  • Winner strength by autonomous community.
    Winner strength by autonomous community.

Aftermath

[edit]

Outcome

[edit]

Initial reactions

[edit]

The 1989 election night was one of the most dramatic since González's first victory in 1982, as PSOE's overall majority in the Congress of Deputies—set at 176—lingered during the entire vote tally. Exit polls and initial counts showed the PSOE below the majority threshold—with as few as 170 seats in some projections—. As the vote tally progressed, the party was allocated more seats, and with 98% of the votes counted at 4 am it was awarded the decisive 176th seat.[58] Earlier in the night, the party's Secretary for Organization Txiki Benegas, Deputy Prime Minister Alfonso Guerra and González himself had commented that, notwithstanding the outcome, the PSOE still remained the largest party by far and would lead the new government on its own, rejecting any coalition deal.[59][60][61] The tight result could not hide the loss of nearly 800,000 voters and a clear erosion in support since 1986, which led opposition parties and some international media—such as the Financial Times, The Independent or The Times—to ask González for a change of direction in government, accusing him of acting "arrogantly" during his previous seven years in office.[62][63]

PP candidate José María Aznar found his party's results as "satisfactory", slightly improving on Fraga's result in 1986.[7] Additionally, the PP had won the election in Madrid for the first time ever, considered as a symbolical feat as both Aznar and González were personally leading their parties's lists in the constituency.[64] IU experienced a remarkable growth by doubling its 1986 results, with its leaders highlighting "the electorate's displacement to the left".[8] On the other hand, the CDS lost votes and seats compared to 1986 and its result was commented as "not the one I expected for" by party leader Adolfo Suárez, who also acknowledged his public image had "deteriorated" in recent times.[9] The breakdown of results would show a noticeable transfer of votes from the PSOE to IU in industrial and urban areas, with the Socialists holding their own in rural constituencies.[65]

Irregularities and judicial intervention

[edit]

During the days after the election, the 176th seat determining the PSOE's absolute majority remained in dispute. PP leaders voiced their concerns over a delay in the Ministry of the Interior's presentation of detailed results during the election night, during which the PSOE was awarded several seats by very few votes in the later stages of the vote tally; seats which ultimately proved decisive for the PSOE retaining its majority.[7] In Barcelona, the PP claimed that its own tallies awarded the PSC–PSOE up to 5,000 votes less than those officially acknowledged by the Ministry, which would have resulted in them winning a 4th seat in the province from the PSC. Additionally, they alleged that this seat had changed hands from the PP to the PSC only when 99.98% of the votes were counted. IU's Julio Anguita criticized the vote tally, openly questioning that "How can [PSOE] go from 172 to 176 seats so fast?". IU announced that they would ask the Electoral Commission to review the voting records of 1,087 polling station wards in the constituency of Murcia, where the last seat had been allocated to PSOE from IU by a narrow margin of 96 votes.[66]

PP claims in Barcelona were cast off after the tally of Spaniards voting abroad gave an even larger margin for the PSC and secured their 14th seat in the constituency.[67] On 5 November, the Electoral Commission found irregularities in Murcia after determining that the number of voters and of ballot papers did not match up in fifteen wards. The new provisional results published on 6 November, which did not include the wards where irregularities had been found, awarded the last seat to PSOE by just two votes.[68][69] Some IU members openly accused the PSOE of fraud, claiming that Socialist intervenors had voted twice in some wards not just in Murcia, but also in Málaga, Madrid and La Rioja—where, however, election results had not been contested—.[70] A new tally on 11 November in Murcia resulted in the Commission awarding the seat to IU, which prompted a PSOE appeal to the Superior Court of Justice of Murcia.[71] Concurrently, both the PP and the CDS alleged to have found irregularities in several polling stations in Melilla and Pontevedra, where seats had been awarded to PSOE by just a handful of votes, and asked for the vote to be annulled in those constituencies.[72] The chaotic situation was further aggravated when, on 22 November, the PP denounced that it had found cases of name duplicity in the electoral register of Ceuta, with the party also demanding for the election to be repeated in Murcia after denouncing irregular procedures by the Electoral Commission during the vote tally.[73][74] The Spanish Attorney General, Javier Moscoso, claimed on 24 November that Murcia's disputed seat belonged to PSOE.[75] On 1 December, the Superior Court of Murcia anulled the election results in the constituency and required the government to call a by-election within three months.[76]

The judicial decision in Murcia raised speculation in other constituencies where results had been appealed that the local Superior Courts would issue similar rulings. This happened in Pontevedra, where the number of counted votes exceeded the number of voters.[77][78][79] Finally, the Superior Court of Andalusia anulled the election results in Melilla, but dismissed the appeal on Ceuta where it declared their validity.[80] González's government announced that it would appeal the decision to the Constitutional Court which, on 25 January 1990, provisionally suspended the scheduled re-run elections in Murcia, Pontevedra and Melilla.[81][82] From 15 to 19 February, the Court overruled the Superior Courts of Justice of Murcia and Galicia and cancelled the re-run elections on Murcia and Pontevedra, declaring the 29 October results as valid and final. For Melilla, it determined that the scale of the detected irregularities was such that the re-run election was required to proceed.[83][5] The election in Melilla on 25 March 1990 gave the constituency's single deputy and its two senators to the PP, thus reducing the PSOE's deputy count to 175.[6] A re-run election was also held on 7 October 1990 in a polling station in Mamblas, Ávila, as the consequence of a judicial conflict between the PP and the CDS over one senator in the constituency, which resulted in the PP winning the disputed senator from the CDS.[84]

Irregularities were found to be a consequence of flawed electoral registers, lack of knowledge on election rules by those appointed to integrate the polling bureaus, a lack of means for the active monitoring of the election process and an inefficient structure of the electoral administration, all of which was coupled with the detection of some illicit votes in several wards. While these flaws had been present in past elections, the closeness of results in the 1989 election and the fact that the PSOE overall majority relied on a single seat meant that these were abruptly exposed. As a result, the electoral law was subsequently amended in 1991 in order to improve the efficiency of the electoral administration.[4][85]

Government formation

[edit]
Further information: Third government of Felipe González
Investiture
Felipe González (PSOE)
Ballot → 5 December 1989
Required majority → 167 out of 332 checkY
Yes
167 / 332
No
  • • PP (99)
  • • CiU (18)
  • • IU–IC (17)
  • • CDS (13)
  • • PA (2)
  • • UV (2)
  • • EA (2)
  • • EE (2)
155 / 332
Abstentions
6 / 332
Absentees
  • • HB (4)
4 / 332
Sources[86]

On 5 December 1989, Felipe González was re-elected as prime minister in the first round of voting with an absolute majority of votes. Although the PSOE had lost its outright majority, due to Herri Batasuna's four deputies declining to take their seats, it had a majority among those deputies who did attend.

As a consequence of seat disputes, only 332 deputies had been sworn in for the investiture, as results for the remaining 18 seats had been temporarily suspended by the Superior Courts. After all 350 seats had been allocated, Prime Minister Felipe González voluntarily submitted himself to a vote of confidence to rectify the atypical investiture vote.[87] The result was essentially a repeat of the December 1989 voting, with some parties previously voting 'No' choosing to abstain. González's parliamentary support remained the same as it was.

Motion of confidence
Felipe González (PSOE)
Ballot → 5 April 1990
Required majority → Simple checkY
Yes
176 / 350
No
  • • PP (105)
  • • IU–IC (16)
  • • PA (2)
  • • UV (2)
  • • EA (2)
  • • EE (2)
  • • PAR (1)
130 / 350
Abstentions
37 / 350
Absentees
7 / 350
Sources[86]

Notes

[edit]
  1. ^ a b Elections re-runs took place in the constituencies of Melilla (Congress and Senate) on 25 March 1990 and Ávila (Senate) on 7 October 1990, as a result of the Constitutional Court annulling the original results due to election irregularities.
  2. ^ Given that HB deputies did not usually take their seats, the number of deputies needed for a majority was in practice slightly lower. HB won 4 seats, meaning a practical majority required at least 174 seats.
  3. ^ a b Results for AP–PDP–PL in the 1986 election.
  4. ^ Article 42 of the General Electoral System Organic Law provided for the election Decree to be issued no later than the twenty-fifth day prior to the date of expiry of Parliament and published on the following day in the Official State Gazette, with polling day taking place between the fifty-fourth and the sixtieth day from publication.[1] This meant that an election was not due until the thirty-sixth day from the legislature's expiry date. As the previous election was held on 22 June 1986, thirty-six days after the Cortes Generales' expiry four years later would have been 28 July 1990.
  5. ^ José Nicolás de Salas, former PL legislator.
  6. ^ Pablo Hurtado, Enric Ribas and Virginio Sánchez Barberán, former PSOE legislators; Juan José Pérez Dobón and Pilar Salarrullana, former DC legislators; Adolfo Careaga and José Manuel Paredes, former PL legislators; José Luis Sánchez Usero, former AP legislator.
  7. ^ José María Bris, José María Herrero, Enrique Marfany and Julio Ulloa, former DC legislators; Pablo Tello, former PSOE legislator; Juan Antón Rueda, former AP legislator.
  8. ^ The percentage of blank ballots is calculated over the official number of valid votes cast, irrespective of the total number of votes shown as a result of adding up the individual results for each party.

References

[edit]
  1. ^ LOREG (1985), tit. I, ch. V, art. 42.
  2. ^ "Zapatero anuncia el séptimo adelanto electoral en democracia". El País (in Spanish). Madrid. 29 July 2011. Retrieved 10 July 2017.
  3. ^ a b "La huelga general paralizó ayer España". El País (in Spanish). 15 December 1988. Retrieved 9 July 2017.
  4. ^ a b Prieto, Joaquín (17 December 1989). "Crisis de la Administración electoral". El País (in Spanish). Madrid. Retrieved 9 July 2017.
  5. ^ a b De la Cuadra, Bonifacio (20 February 1990). "Melilla repetirá las elecciones legislativas". El País (in Spanish). Madrid. Retrieved 9 July 2017.
  6. ^ a b Grijelmo, Álex (26 March 1990). "La derecha agrupó sus votos para vencer al PSOE". El País (in Spanish). Melilla. Retrieved 9 July 2017.
  7. ^ a b c González Ibáñez, Juan (30 October 1989). "Aznar, safisfecho por haber roto el techo electoral de la derecha conservadora". El País (in Spanish). Madrid. Retrieved 9 July 2017.
  8. ^ a b Mauri, Luis (30 October 1989). "Julio Anguita destaca el desplazamiento del electorado hacia la izquierda". El País (in Spanish). Madrid. Retrieved 9 July 2017.
  9. ^ a b "Adolfo Suarez reconoce que no ha obtenido los resultados que esperaba". El País (in Spanish). Madrid. 30 October 1989. Retrieved 9 July 2017.
  10. ^ Const. Esp. (1978), tit. III, ch. I, art. 66.
  11. ^ "Sinopsis artículo 66". Constitución española (in Spanish). Congress of Deputies. Retrieved 12 September 2020, summarizing Const. Esp. (1978), tit. III, ch. I, art. 66.
  12. ^ LOREG (1985), tit. I, ch. I, art. 2.
  13. ^ Carreras de Odriozola & Tafunell Sambola 2005, p. 1077.
  14. ^ Const. Esp. (1978), tit. III, ch. I, art. 68.
  15. ^ LOREG (1985), tit. II, ch. III, art. 162–164.
  16. ^ Gallagher, Michael (30 July 2012). "Effective threshold in electoral systems". Trinity College, Dublin. Archived from the original on 30 July 2017. Retrieved 22 July 2017.
  17. ^ a b "Real Decreto 1047/1989, de 1 de septiembre, de disolución del Congreso de los Diputados y del Senado y de convocatoria de elecciones" (PDF). Boletín Oficial del Estado (in Spanish) (210): 28094. 2 September 1989. ISSN 0212-033X.
  18. ^ Const. Esp. (1978), tit. III, ch. I, art. 69.
  19. ^ LOREG (1985), tit. II, ch. III, art. 162 & 165–166.
  20. ^ LOREG (1985), tit. I, ch. V, art. 42.
  21. ^ Const. Esp. (1978), tit. IV, art. 99.
  22. ^ "El PSOE cree que repetirá mayoría absoluta si adelanta las eleciones". El País (in Spanish). Madrid. 29 July 1989. Retrieved 9 July 2017.
  23. ^ Díez, Anabel (30 July 1989). "Felipe González, casi decidido a convocar elecciones antes de adoptar medidas de ajuste económico". El País (in Spanish). Madrid. Retrieved 9 July 2017.
  24. ^ González Ibáñez, Juan (24 August 1989). "González opta por celebrar en domingo las elecciones anticipadas". El País (in Spanish). Madrid. Retrieved 9 July 2017.
  25. ^ González Ibáñez, Juan (26 August 1989). "González convocará las legislativas para el 29 de octubre". El País (in Spanish). Madrid. Retrieved 10 August 2017.
  26. ^ "España: El PIB ascendió un 4,8%". datosmacro.com (in Spanish). Retrieved 9 July 2017.
  27. ^ "Datos desde 1976, del número de: Afiliados a la Seguridad Social, Parados y Tasa de Paro y Ocupados". javiersevillano.es (in Spanish). Retrieved 9 July 2017.
  28. ^ "Felipe González afirma que el PSOE hará autocrítica sobre el retroceso electoral". El País (in Spanish). Madrid. 14 June 1987. Retrieved 9 July 2017.
  29. ^ "La transición política. La Constitución de 1978 y el Estado de las Autonomías". historiasiglo20.org (in Spanish). Retrieved 9 July 2017.
  30. ^ Vargas, Jairo (13 December 2013). "14-D, 25 años de la huelga que paralizó España". Público (in Spanish). Madrid. Retrieved 9 July 2017.
  31. ^ "Manuel Fraga dimite como presidente de Alianza Popular". El País (in Spanish). 2 December 1986. Retrieved 9 July 2017.
  32. ^ "Antonio Hernández Mancha fue descalificado por la oposición sin necesidad de que interviniera el Gobierno". El País (in Spanish). Madrid. 27 March 1987. Retrieved 9 July 2017.
  33. ^ Garea, Fernando (10 June 2017). "Tercera moción de censura imposible". El País (in Spanish). Retrieved 9 July 2017.
  34. ^ "Hernández Mancha presenta una moción de censura contra el Gobierno Felipe González, sin posibilidades de ganarla". La Hemeroteca del Buitre (in Spanish). 1 March 1987. Retrieved 9 July 2017.
  35. ^ González Ibáñez, Juan; Prieto, Joaquín (25 October 1988). "Fraga desembarca en AP con el apoyo de los 'pesos fuertes' y deja a Mancha sólo con su equipo". El País (in Spanish). Madrid. Retrieved 9 July 2017.
  36. ^ González Ibáñez, Juan (4 January 1989). "Hernández Mancha renuncia a competir con Fraga". El País (in Spanish). Madrid. Retrieved 9 July 2017.
  37. ^ "Fraga se empleó a fondo para lograr que el congreso de AP cambie el nombre del partido". El País (in Spanish). Madrid. 21 January 1989. Retrieved 9 July 2017.
  38. ^ "9º Congreso de AP – Fraga recupera el poder del partido y cambia su nombre por el de 'Partido Popular' tras apartar a Mancha". La Hemeroteca del Buitre (in Spanish). 22 January 1989. Retrieved 9 July 2017.
  39. ^ Díez, Anabel (19 August 1989). "Jose María Aznar, el candidato preferido por los 'populares'". El País (in Spanish). Madrid. Retrieved 9 July 2017.
  40. ^ González Ibáñez, Juan (30 August 1989). "Fraga ha comunicado a José María Aznar que es su candidato para la presidencia del Gobierno". El País (in Spanish). Madrid. Retrieved 9 July 2017.
  41. ^ Sullivan, Ian (14 January 2017). "Thousands protest Spain's dispersion policy for ETA inmates". US News. Bilbao. Retrieved 3 January 2018.
  42. ^ "ETA ofrece una tregua al Estado para "negociar" en Argelia un mes después de asesinar a cinco niñas en la Casa Cuartel de Zaragoza". La Hemeroteca del Buitre (in Spanish). 30 January 1988. Retrieved 9 July 2017.
  43. ^ "ETA rompe la tregua y suaviza sus exigencias para reanudar el dialogo". El País (in Spanish). 5 April 1989. Retrieved 9 July 2017.
  44. ^ "El Gobierno cierra el diálogo con ETA y anuncia acciones internacionales". El País (in Spanish). 11 April 1989. Retrieved 9 July 2017.
  45. ^ "Grupos Parlamentarios en el Congreso de los Diputados y el Senado". Historia Electoral.com (in Spanish). Retrieved 29 October 2022.
  46. ^ a b "Composición del Senado 1977-2024". Historia Electoral.com (in Spanish). Retrieved 29 October 2022.
  47. ^ "Grupos parlamentarios". Congress of Deputies (in Spanish). Retrieved 7 December 2020.
  48. ^ "Grupos Parlamentarios desde 1977". Senate of Spain (in Spanish). Retrieved 7 December 2020.
  49. ^ LOREG (1985), tit. I, ch. VI, art. 44 & tit. II, ch. V, art. 169.
  50. ^ "Acuerdo electoral entre UPN y el Partido Popular". El País (in Spanish). Madrid. 9 September 1989. Retrieved 7 January 2018.
  51. ^ Díez, Anabel (15 October 1989). "González explica como "una reflexión racional" su alusión a que ésta es su última cita con las urnas". El País (in Spanish). Alcázar de San Juan. Retrieved 7 January 2018.
  52. ^ a b c d e "De 1977 a 2015, los carteles electorales de la democracia". El Confidencial (in Spanish). 3 December 2015. Retrieved 7 January 2018.
  53. ^ a b "Así han evolucionado los lemas electorales en España". La Gaceta (in Spanish). 27 November 2015. Archived from the original on 12 December 2015. Retrieved 7 January 2018.
  54. ^ a b c "Los lemas que ganaron elecciones". Ciudadanos en crisis (in Spanish). 8 November 2011. Retrieved 7 January 2018.
  55. ^ a b "Elecciones celebradas. Resultados electorales". Ministry of the Interior (in Spanish). Retrieved 15 April 2022.
  56. ^ a b "Elecciones Generales 29 de octubre de 1989". Historia Electoral.com (in Spanish). Retrieved 21 October 2021.
  57. ^ "Elecciones al Senado 1989". Historia Electoral.com (in Spanish). Retrieved 24 September 2017.
  58. ^ "El PSOE obtiene su tercera mayoría absoluta". El País (in Spanish). 30 October 1989. Retrieved 9 July 2017.
  59. ^ "Felipe González asegura que el PSOE deberá asumir de nuevo "la responsabilidad de gobernar"". El País (in Spanish). Madrid. 30 October 1989. Retrieved 9 July 2017.
  60. ^ "El 'baile' de un escaño puso en vilo la mayoría absoluta". El País (in Spanish). Madrid. 30 October 1989. Retrieved 9 July 2017.
  61. ^ Brunet, José María (30 October 1989). "El PSOE logra la tercera mayoría absoluta". La Vanguardia (in Spanish). Madrid. Retrieved 9 July 2017.
  62. ^ "El PSOE sufre un duro correctivo electoral y gana "in extremis" la mayoría absoluta". ABC (in Spanish). Madrid. 30 October 1989. Retrieved 9 July 2017.
  63. ^ Martínez de Rituerto, Ricardo (1 November 1989). "El 'Times' sugiere a González que atienda las protestas para asegurar estabilidad". El País (in Spanish). Londres. Retrieved 9 July 2017.
  64. ^ "El PP fue la fuerza más votada en Madrid". El País (in Spanish). Madrid. 30 October 1989. Retrieved 9 July 2017.
  65. ^ "El PSOE pierde escaños de las zonas industriales". El País (in Spanish). Madrid. 31 October 1989. Retrieved 9 July 2017.
  66. ^ Uria, Lluis (1 November 1989). "La oposición trata de arañar el escaño de la mayoría absoluta socialista en el recuento final". El País (in Spanish). Barcelona. Retrieved 9 July 2017.
  67. ^ Uria, Lluis (4 November 1989). "Aumenta la diferencia entre PSC y populares en Barcelona". El País (in Spanish). Barcelona. Retrieved 9 July 2017.
  68. ^ Martínez, Guillem (6 November 1989). "Halladas irregularidades en 10 mesas electorales de Murcia". El País (in Spanish). Murcia. Retrieved 9 July 2017.
  69. ^ "El PSOE mantiene la mayoría absoluta al adjudicarse el quinto escaño de Murcia por dos votos". El País (in Spanish). Madrid. 7 November 1989. Retrieved 9 July 2017.
  70. ^ Mercado, Francisco (14 November 1989). "La Junta Electoral de Murcia remite al juez el presunto doble voto de interventores socialistas". El País (in Spanish). Madrid. Retrieved 9 July 2017.
  71. ^ Méndez, Juan; Díez, Anabel (12 November 1989). "El PSOE califica de "anómalo" el escrutinio en Murcia tras perder el escaño de la mayoría absoluta". El País (in Spanish). Madrid. Retrieved 9 July 2017.
  72. ^ "El PP intenta que se anulen las votaciones en un colegio de Melilla". El País (in Spanish). Madrid. 5 November 1989. Retrieved 9 July 2017.
  73. ^ González Ibáñez, Juan (23 November 1989). "El Partido Popular denuncia muchos casos de duplicidad de nombres en el censo de Ceuta". El País (in Spanish). Madrid. Retrieved 9 July 2017.
  74. ^ "El Partido Popular solicita que se repitan las elecciones legislativas en Murcia". El País (in Spanish). Murcia. 24 November 1989. Retrieved 9 July 2017.
  75. ^ Yoldi, José (25 November 1989). "El fiscal del Estado afirma que el escaño de Murcia es de los socialistas". El País (in Spanish). Madrid. Retrieved 9 July 2017.
  76. ^ Rocamora, José (2 December 1989). "El Gobierno deberá convocar nuevas elecciones de diputados en Murcia en el plazo de tres meses". El País (in Spanish). Madrid. Retrieved 9 July 2017.
  77. ^ Palmeiro, Xosé María (4 December 1989). "Más votos que votantes en Pontevedra". El País (in Spanish). Vigo. Retrieved 9 July 2017.
  78. ^ "Los jueces ordenan repetir las elecciones también en Pontevedra". El País (in Spanish). 4 December 1989. Retrieved 9 July 2017.
  79. ^ "La repetición de elecciones en Pontevedra agudiza el clima de bochorno para la democracia española". ABC (in Spanish). Madrid. 4 December 1989. Retrieved 10 July 2017.
  80. ^ B. Castilla, Elena (6 December 1989). "Los jueces ordenan repetir las elecciones en Melilla". El País (in Spanish). Málaga. Retrieved 9 July 2017.
  81. ^ "El PSOE recurrirá las anulaciones de Murcia y Galicia". El País (in Spanish). Madrid. 4 December 1989. Retrieved 9 July 2017.
  82. ^ Yoldi, José (26 January 1990). "El Tribunal Constitucional congela las sentencias sobre las elecciones en Murcia, Pontevedra y Melilla". El País (in Spanish). Madrid. Retrieved 9 July 2017.
  83. ^ De la Cuadra, Bonifacio (16 February 1990). "El Constitucional hace depender la mayoría absoluta del PSOE de los electores de dos mesas de Murcia". El País (in Spanish). Madrid. Retrieved 9 July 2017.
  84. ^ De Miguel, Carlos (8 October 1990). "El PP recupera un senador por Ávila tras repetirse los comicios en Mamblas". El País (in Spanish). Ávila. Retrieved 9 July 2017.
  85. ^ "Reforma electoral". El País (in Spanish). 10 March 1991. Retrieved 10 July 2017.
  86. ^ a b "Congreso de los Diputados: Votaciones más importantes". Historia Electoral.com (in Spanish). Retrieved 28 September 2017.
  87. ^ "Constitución española, Sinopsis artículo 112". congreso.es (in Spanish). Congress of Deputies. Retrieved 19 September 2017.

Bibliography

[edit]
[edit]
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=1989_Spanish_general_election&oldid=1265736320"